Data loss on JBODs

By -
After a disasterous data loss coused by the raid system I have changed all to JBOD assuming that 1/8 data loss is more acceptable than a full disaster.

Wrong. If you have eight drives in JBOD, and one of them dies, there are several options:
  • On NTFS filesystem, if first drive dies, the entire array is lost. If any other drive dies, 7/8th of the data is lost.

  • On ext-whatever, you can salvage an unspecified amount of data because the superblocks are distributed more-or-less evenly across the volume. However, everything in disk groups which span across two disks is likely lost. So you can theoretically approach "1/8th of the data lost", but that involves using some data recovery software and is far from easy.

If you want to be sure that the loss is limited to 1/8th of data in eight-disk configuration, forget JBOD and create eight separate volumes instead.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

QNAP revisited

By Geek -
For reference, we were using QNAP TS-639 Pro with six WD20EADS disks. After about half a year of use, the web-interface was running slower, so that we needed to wait for several minutes to obtain the list of the disks. Gradually, we noted that the array performance decreased significantly. It seemed obvious to assume that one of the member disks has been dropped from the array and a RAID5 was working in the degraded mode. However, all the member disks were marked as GOOD in the web-interface. It was suspicious that LEDs on the disk bays indicating the state and activity of the disks were blinking unevenly. Logically, for RAID5 one should expect almost symmetric load on the disks, but in fact, one of the disk LED was blinking much more frequently. Once we had run the bad blocks check on this disk through the web-interface, the disk dropped from the array in less than half an hour and its bay LED turned red. At this point, the web-interface began to work properly again. The disk taken fr
Read more

APFS Data Recovery

By -
Apple File System, APFS for short, is a brand-new filesystem released in 2017. The goal is to replace HFS+ which has been in use on Apple computers since 1998. Formally released in late 2017, APFS filesystem began to be used by default on Apple computers running under MacOS High Sierra. Among the main features of APFS filesystem are 64-bit pointers allowing to address 2^56 blocks More accurate created/accesses/modification time measured in nanoseconds since 1970-01-01 Copy-on-write Sharing blocks between APFS volumes Native full-disk encryption We are happy to announce that now ReclaiMe data recovery software is capable of recovering data from APFS-formatted devices be it a USB thumb drive, or external hard drive, or internal SSD boot drive. You can download the latest build of ReclaiMe at www.ReclaiMe.com .
Read more